TLDR
A Toll Transport LPG tanker driver lost his job and a Fair Work challenge after using smartglasses to photograph equipment inside a live gas terminal at Hastings, Victoria. Federal Circuit Court Judge Karl Blake found the dismissal was justified on safety grounds, rejecting claims it was retaliation.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Driver sacked after using smartglasses inside live gas facility
An LPG tanker driver has lost both his job and a federal court challenge after using smartglasses to photograph equipment inside a live gas terminal in Victoria. Federal Circuit and Family Court Judge Karl Blake dismissed Ricardo Martins Silva's Fair Work Act claim, finding Toll Transport sacked him because he wore the device at the Long Island Point LPG terminal in Hastings, not because he had made workplace complaints.[1]
Martins Silva had argued the dismissal, which took effect in July 2025, was retaliation for grievances he raised about truck allocations, safety and working conditions. Judge Blake rejected that account.
What the judge found
Judge Blake was direct about the gravity of what occurred at the terminal. He found the glasses incident was "on any objective view a serious incident", adding: "It was objectively very serious."[1]
Toll treated the episode as a critical safety breach, suspended Martins Silva and then ended his employment. The court found that sequence flowed from the smartglasses incident, not from any effort to silence complaints.[1]
Why smartglasses raise the stakes at a fuel facility
WorkSafe Victoria warns that electrical equipment can ignite a flammable atmosphere in a hazardous fuel area, creating a risk of fire and serious injury, and that occupiers must keep ignition sources out of hazardous areas so far as reasonably practicable.[3] LPG facilities can contain areas where vapour may form an explosive atmosphere, meaning equipment unremarkable in an office becomes a potential ignition source on site.
Smartglasses are battery-powered electronic devices carrying cameras and wireless radios. Unless selected and certified specifically for use in a classified hazardous area, their presence in such zones raises the same concerns WorkSafe attaches to ordinary electrical equipment.
The policy Toll relied on
Toll's compliance policy states that safety is paramount, applies to both employees and contractors, and permits disciplinary action up to and including termination for breaches of that policy.[2] Toll relied on those provisions when it moved to dismiss Martins Silva after the terminal incident.
Judge Blake handed down his decision last week. It is the first reported case in Australia of a worker dismissed for using smartglasses in a workplace.[1]
SOURCES & CITATIONS
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS




