TLDR
Premier Chris Minns has delayed NSW underquoting reforms by more than a year, pushing the new price-guide rules to December 2027. Sydney dwelling values have fallen 10.1 per cent from their February 2026 peak, the market shift Minns cited as exposing a flaw in the legislation.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Reforms shelved days before they were due to start
NSW Premier Chris Minns has shelved a toughened underquoting crackdown that was scheduled to take effect on 17 November, pushing the reforms back to 1 December 2027, more than a year past the original start date.[1] Underquoting occurs when an agent advertises or quotes a price below what the vendor would genuinely accept, a practice that wastes buyers' time and distorts the market.
The package that never commenced would have required a selling price or range in every residential advertisement, updates to non-compliant online listings within one business day, the use of three comparable sales to support any price estimate, detailed record-keeping and penalties of up to $110,000 or three times the agent's commission.[2] NSW Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading Anoulack Chanthivong said when the start dates were announced that buyers deserve clear and reliable information when deciding what they can afford, so that they're not wasting their time or their hard-earned money.[2]
The rule that tripped up a falling market
The provision that proved most problematic barred an agent from suggesting a price below a written offer the vendor had already rejected on grounds the offer was too low, as well as below the highest known bid where a property passed in at auction.[3] In a rising market that rule is straightforward; in a falling market, it can lock an advertised price to a figure the vendor has since decided to move below.
Minns said falling property prices had created an unforeseen consequence because agents could be prevented from lowering an advertised price when a vendor later accepted a lower market value.[5] "It's not the seller or the agent's fault if the price of real estate is dropping," Minns said.[5] Existing obligations remain in force: agents must maintain a reasonable estimated selling price, revise it when it is no longer reasonable and must not advertise or quote below the estimate in the agency agreement.[1]
Sydney values down more than 10 per cent from peak
Cotality's latest index shows Sydney dwelling values have dropped 10.1 per cent from their February peak, and they were still falling in October.[4]
That is the scenario Minns said the rejected-offer rule could not accommodate.
Reaction from industry and opposition
Real Estate Institute of NSW chief executive Tim McKibbin said the rejected-offer rule would disadvantage both buyers and vendors. "It misleads and disadvantages those purchasers and it certainly disadvantages the vendor," McKibbin said.[5] McKibbin said the rule would have stopped buyers learning that a property had become more affordable.
NSW Shadow Fair Trading Minister Tim James offered less sympathy for the government's position, saying "property prices move in cycles" was a basic premise any legislation should have been built around from the start.[5] Buyers' advocates lose the stronger enforcement framework, including the comparable-sales requirement, the one-business-day correction window and the higher penalty cap, until at least 1 December 2027.[1]
SOURCES & CITATIONS
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS




